Ocean Salinity

Ocean Salinity

This article deals with ‘Oceanography: Ocean Salinity’ This is part of our series on ‘Geography’ which is important pillar of GS-1 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Introduction

  • Salinity of Solution is defined as amount of salt in 1000 gram of water .
  • Salinity of ocean water is 35.5 ppt ( parts per thousand)  & maximum amount is of common salt.
Sodium chloride 78%
Magnesium Chloride 12%
Magnesium sulphate 3.5%
Calcium Sulphate 2.5%

Why Sodium Chloride (NaCl) is present in highest proportion ?

  • Every salt has cycle & they remain in sea water for specific time( called residual time) & then precipitated to bottom surface .
  • Sodium (Na) & Chlorine (Cl) has highest residual time in ocean water leading to very gradual removal => that is why they are present in highest proportion .

Salt Budget

  • Irrespective of absolute salinity,  proportion of above salts remain same in all parts of the world  .
  • Amount of addition or extraction of fresh water compared to salt content in ocean water decides absolute salinity of oceans .
  • Salt Budget  = Budget of addition of salt & removal of salt .

Sources of salts on ocean water.

  • Sediments carried by rivers (most important) .
  • Submarine volcanism at Mid Oceanic Ridge .
  • Chemical reaction between rocks of geothermal vent of volcano & cold water.
  • Erosion of oceanic rocks and wave erosion of coastal rocks  .

Removal of Salts in ocean water.

  • Physical Removal :  waves break at beaches ie salt spray .
  • Biological removal : marine life forms extract calcium from sea water for their bones & shells .

Factors effecting salinity

Evaporation Higher the rate of evaporation ,higher is salinity.
Temperature Warmer parts are more saline than frigid ones.
Precipitation Higher the precipitation, lower is the salinity.
Influx of Freshwater Influx of freshwater leads to lower salinity .
Atmospheric pressure  
Circulation of Ocean water Stagnant water has more salinity (Eg: Sargasso sea).
Windy situation Wind accelerate evaporation => windy situation = more saline

Salinity of Oceans

  • Standard  salinity of ocean water is 35.5 ppt ie salinity of Atlantic ocean .
Greater than 35.5 High saline.
Lower than 35.5 Less  saline.
  • Some highly saline lakes . Man  seldom drown in sea with high salinity because water is  highly dense .
Dead Sea 238 ppt West Asia
Lake Van 330 ppt Turkey
Great Salt Lake 220 ppt USA
Lake Urmia   Iran

Overall pattern of Salinity across world

Ocean Salinity

a. Latitudinal variation

  • Salinity is highest at tropics(not Equator)  & decreases on both sides.
  • This is due to Interplay of evaporation & precipitation & other complex interactions.

b. Hemispheric variation

  • Northern Hemisphere is warmer => high evaporation => more saline .
  • But southern Pacific => Roaring 40, furious 50 , Shreaking 60 , Screaming 70 => very fast winds . Hence in Pacific ocean , southern hemisphere has more salinity

c. Local Variation in Salinity

Warm ocean currents – Increases temperature of water => equivalent to High evaporation .
– Leads to more salinity.
Upwelling Cooler water from depth come to surface => low salinity.
Transport by currents The North Sea, in spite of its location in higher latitudes, records higher salinity due to more saline water brought by the North Atlantic Drift.

d. Enclosed Seas

Tropical region – Warmer than open sea .
– Will lead to high salinity.
– Eg Mediterranean Sea , Persian Gulf etc. 
High Latitude – Cooler than open sea .
– Lower salinity than open seas .
– Eg Baltic Sea, Gulf of Bothnia etc .

e. Inflow of large rivers

  • Ganga – Brahmaputra => flow into Bay of Bengal => large freshwater .
  • Bay of Bengal is less saline than Arabian Sea.

f. Glaciers

  • Those oceans /seas which receive greater glacier water are less saline
  • Baltic Sea is very less saline because of this reason .

Ocean Temperature

Ocean Temperature

This article deals with ‘Oceanography: Ocean Temperature’ This is part of our series on ‘Geography’ which is important pillar of GS-1 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Introduction

  • Temperature of ocean water is important because
    1. Life of Phytoplankton & Zooplankton depend on it .
    2. Affects climate of coastal lands .
  • Points to note :-
    1. Main source of Energy on Earth is sun ie insolation .
    2. Oceans play important role in energy & temperature regulation of earth. Because of its specific heat, water doesn’t  get heated &  does-not get cold very fast . Hence, water  can store energy for very long time .
    3. Average temperature of ocean from surface to bottom is 3-5  Celsius.
    4. But average surface temperature of ocean is 25 Celsius.

Range of temperature

Daily/ Diurnal range of temperature

  • Difference between maximum & minimum temperature of a day.
  • Daily range of temperature is almost insignificant in case of rivers & is less than 1 degree C at max
  • Tropical water has higher diurnal range than equatorial waters because cooling & heating of water is rapid under clear sky .

Annual range of temperature

Average is 12 degree C but lot of regional variation.

  • Higher in case of enclosed oceans than open seas
  • Bigger the size lower annual range of temp because of more mixing .

Distribution pattern of Temperature

Studied in two ways

1 . Horizontal  distribution of temperature in oceans

Factors impacting horizontal distribution of temperature in oceans

a. Latitudinal Variation

  • There is decrease in temperature while going from equator toward poles because of decrease in insolation
  • But highest temperature is found not at equator but at tropics
    • Reason : High rainfall & cloud cover at the Equator resulting in High Albedo / reflection of sun-rays by clouds

b. Prevailing Winds

Direction of the wind affects the distribution of temperature of ocean water.

  • Off shore winds blowing from the land towards ocean or sea raise the temperature of ocean water.
  • Winds blowing from snow covered regions in winter lower the surface temperature

c. Hemispheric Variation

  • Waters in Northern Hemisphere warmer than Southern Hemisphere . Reason is the oceans in the northern hemisphere receive more heat due to their contact with larger extent of land than the oceans in the southern hemisphere.
  • Isotherms in north aren’t regular while in Southern Hemisphere regular.

d. Enclosed Sea

  • Marginal seas of tropics ( like Mediterranean Sea)  are warmer than open Ocean and marginal seas of  temperate region (eg Gulf of Bothnia)  are cooler than open sea.
  • Reasons
    • less mixing of water.
    • Land heats up surrounding waters too.

e. Ocean Currents

  • Warm currents have warming effect on ocean water
  • Cold currents have cooling effect on ocean water

f. Upwelling & Downwelling

  • Upwelling – Brings cool water from depth.
  • Downwelling – opposite ie warmer .

g. Salinity

  • If the sea water is more saline, its temperature will be higher because highly saline water contains more energy on the other hand the temperature of less saline water is low.

Horizontal distribution of Ocean Temperature

  • The average temperature of surface water of the oceans at equator is about 27°C and it gradually decreases from the equator towards the poles.
  • The rate of decrease of temperature with increasing latitude is generally 0.5°C per latitude
  • The average temperature is around 22°C at 20° latitudes, 14° C at 40° latitudes and 0° C near poles.
  • The oceans in the northern hemisphere record relatively higher temperature than in the southern hemisphere. The average annual temperatures for the northern and southern hemisphere are around 19° C and 16° C respectively. This variation is due to the unequal distribution of land and water in the northern and southern hemispheres.
  • The highest temperature is not recorded at the equator but slightly towards north of it.
800N— 
400N 
00 
800S 
32 
30 
28 
26 
24 
22 
20 
18 
16 
14 
12 
10 
500F 
V. 
1500F 
LONGITUDE 
Figure 5.12 Sea surface temperature in July 1997

2. Vertical Distribution of Temperature of Ocean Waters

  • Maximum temperature is on the surface  because it receives insolation.
  • Transmitted to lower sections of ocean by convection.
  • Solar rays can penetrate very effectively till 200m  but seldom go below 1000 m . As a result, temperature falls very rapidly from 200m  till 1000m & after that , rate of decrease of temperature is very slow (rate & not absolute temperature).

Can be divided into three zones

First layer

  • Top layer of warm oceanic water & is 200 m thick.
  • Temperature ranges from  20 to 25degree  & no large variation with depth ( almost constant )
  • Present in tropics throughout year , in mid latitudes in summer & in cold areas never present .

Second layer

  • Thermocline layer
  • Below first layer from 200m to 1000 m.
  • Rapid rate of decrease of temperature to 4 C  with increase in depth from 200 m to 1000 m .
  • Rate of decrease is rapid at equator & tropics than towards pole because temperature already is very low in Polar Region
  • In polar , waters  are already at around 4C . Hence, this layer is not present in polars .

Third layer

  • Very cold & extend upto deep ocean floor.
  • Decrease in temperature with depth is almost nill.
  • Polar areas have only this layer from above till ocean floor.
Vertical pattern of temperature of Oceans

Ocean Currents, Waves, Tides and Thermo-Haline Circulations

Table of Contents

Ocean Currents, Waves, Tides and Thermo-Haline Circulations

This article deals with ‘Oceanography: Ocean Currents, Waves, Tides and Thermo-Haline Circulations.’ This is part of our series on ‘Geography’ which is important pillar of GS-1 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Introduction

Major movements of ocean water can be categorised as follows:-

1 . Horizontal Movement : Waves

The waves are oscillating movements in the ocean water which transfer energy from place to place.

Creation of waves

  • Wind pushes (away) the water body & creates crest.
  • Gravity pulls the crest downward & falling water pushes the former troughs upward .
  • Actual motion of water beneath wave is circular (& not straight)  & while we go downward movement of water molecules keep on decreasing.
  • Hence, in waves very slow horizontal movement of water  takes place .

Waves  actually involves the transfer of energy and water particles don’t move across the sea/ocean as such. Water particles only moves in circular pattern as wave passes. Wind causes waves to travel in ocean and energy is released at the shore.

2 . Horizontal Movement : Currents

  • Large mass of moving water from one part of the ocean to another in a definite direction is called as ocean current.
  • The movement is produced due to earth’s rotation, temperature difference of ocean water, salinity, density , air pressure and winds.
  • They circumnavigate the earth .
Ocean Currents

What Currents do

  • Heat re-distribution – from  Equator to Poles.
    •  warm water from equator to poles .
    •  cold water from poles to equator.

Factors responsible for ocean current

The primary forces that influence the currents are:

a. Wind

  • Most dominated force.
  • In most cases, direction of wind will be direction of underlying current .

b. Insolation

  • Heating by solar energy cause the water to expand. That is why, near  equator the ocean water is about 8 cm higher in level than in the middle latitudes.
  • This causes a very slight gradient and water tends to flow down the slope. 

c. Salinity

  • Water will move from lower salinity to higher salinity on the surface .
  • Reason : Water with higher salinity being denser sinks & as a result water with low salinity comes to fill the space. 
  • Eg : Water from Atlantic flows to Mediterranean

d. Coriolis Force

Coriolis Effect : Due to rotation of earth – West to East .

  • Object moving in Northern Hemisphere will deflect Clockwise
  • Object moving in Southern Hemisphere will deflect Anti Clockwise
Coriolis Effect of the Earth

Movement of currents should be straight from equator to pole but not straight because

  • Coastline modifies the path.
  • Coriolis force

Nomenclature : Warm Current & Cold Current

  • Warm current is one that carry water warmer than water found at that latitude .
  • Water flowing from low latitude to higher latitude is warm.

Currents effect climate of bordering landmass eg wind blowing to land from warm current cause rainfall. This is the  reason why mostly east coasts of continents receive rainfall & west coasts are deserts.

General Pattern of Currents in all Oceans

  • Due to rotation of earth from west to east  , two currents one on each side of equator are formed called North & South Equatorial Current.
  • Water carried in form of Equatorial currents tend to accumulate in western part of ocean or eastern coast of continent.
  • To balance this Counter Equatorial Current is formed between two Equatorial Currents from West to East.
  • Water at eastern coast of continent start piling up & under influence of density gradient start moving towards middle latitudes
  • At same time high density water at poles start flowing towards equator in form of currents along eastern coast of continent & two meet in middle latitudes where cold water sinks & warm water spreads on it .
  • The water is pushed towards east by strong westerlies & water reaches eastern part of ocean or western coast of other continent.
  • Obstruction at western part of continent divides water & one moves toward pole & other toward equator.
  • The water sinked in middle latitude upwells along the western coast to make good removal of water at equator . As a result circulatory cells known as gyres are formed one in each major ocean basin & is situated between 20 to 30 degree in both hemisphere.
  • This system is found in all oceans except Indian ocean where major changes occur due to presence of Indian peninsula &  seasonal reversal of winds producing double gyre moving in seasonally opposite directions.

2.1 Currents in Atlantic Ocean

N.Atlantc 
Drift 
Gulf Strearn 
Canary 
N.Equatorial 
Eq.latorid 
Counter 
S. Equatorial 
Peru 
rctic Circumpolar 
ntarctic Subpolat 
Brazil 
Benguela 
South Atlantic 
Antarctic Sub dar

Warm Currents in Atlantic Ocean

a. North Equatorial Current

  • North equatorial current flows from east to west between 5– 20 N latitudes.
  • After leaving the west coast of Africa, it attains its main characteristics.
  • When it reaches the east coast of South America, it splits into two branches and one branch called Antilles current moves along the coast of West Indies and other branch is diverted into the Caribbean sea.

b. South Equatorial current

  • It  flows south of equator within 0 – 12 S latitude in between the coast of Africa and South America.
  • It is stronger than the North equatorial ocean current

c. Gulf Stream

  • Gulf Stream starts from the Gulf of Mexico and carries warm waters into the colder latitudes.
  • It bends with the coastline up to 40th parallel after which the direction is almost to the east, due to the force and the direction of the westerlies and the deflective force of the earth.
  • It joins the Labrador cold current near New Found land, Canada  making it a good fishing ground.

d. Brazil Current

  • Warm current moving south along the coast of Brazil.
  • It joins the Falkland cold current near Bahia Blanca  making it a good fishing ground.

e. Norwegian Current /North Atlantic Drift

  • Norwegian Current takes warm water towards the coast of Norway allowing it’s coast to be operational throughout the year.

Cold Currents of Atlantic Ocean

a. Canary Island

  • It flows south  along the Western coast of North Africa between Maderia and Cape verde
  • Gradually , it merges with the North equatorial current.

b. Labrador Current

  • In the north Atlantic, it flows from the Baffin Bay and Davis Strait towards south.
  •  It brings cold waters from polar zone and moves along the coast of green land.
  • It meets with warm Gulf Stream near New Found Land making it a good fishing ground.

c. Benguela Current

  • It flows northward along the western coast of Africa
  • It carries cold waters from sub-Antarctica surface water and mixes with south equatorial current

Side note : Newfound Land Island

Newfound Land Islands
  • Meeting point of Gulf Stream( warm current) & Labrador current (cold Current)
  • Amount of planktons increases resulting in large number of fishes. Hence, it is Good fishing ground.

Side Note: North Atlantic Drift / Norwegian Current

North Atlantic Drift / Norwegian Current
  • It provides warming effect to western Europe.
  • Due to this, ports of Norway –  Narvik,  Hammerfest , Murmansk etc keep on operating in winter but at same latitude ports in Russia freeze during winter .

Side Note : Canary Current and Sahara Desert

  • Canary current is cold current(passes near Canary Islands).
  • They give desiccating effect (drying effect)  to Sahara Desert resulting in no rainfall .

Side Note : Sargasso Sea

Sargasso Sea
  • It is the only sea in the world without a land boundary.  Its boundaries are defined only by ocean currents. It is encircled by the Gulf Stream in the west, north Atlantic drift in the north, Canary current in the east and North Equatorial and Antilles current in the south
  • Due to confinement , Sargassum ie a sea weed grow in this region which obstructs navigation. Plants have become adapted to life in the open sea, need no roots or holdfasts for attachment, and are able to propagate by breaking off bits to grow into new plants through vegetative propagation.
  • It is very saline. Reasons for this are
    • Prevention of mixing of fresh water from surrounding oceans due to virtual boundary created by the ocean currents.
    • High Evaporation due to high temperature owing to its subtropical location
    • Gulf Stream brings in high salinity water to the sea.
  • It is devoid of nutrients & hence, poor marine life .

Side Note : Bahia Blanca & Falkland Island

  • Meeting point of warm Brazilian & cold Falkland Current .
  • Important for fishing activity.
Brazilian 
Current 
Benguela 
Current 
I nd 
I and 
Falkland 
Current

Side Note : Benguela Current & Namib Desert

  • Benguela Current is a Cold Current.
  • It gives  desiccating effect leading to low rainfall on the south-west coast of Africa and formation of  Namib Desert.
Benguela 
Current 
Namib 
Desert 
O

2.2 Currents of Pacific Current

Cold Currents of Pacific Ocean

a. Oyashio current

  • It originates from the Bering Strait and flows towards south carrying cold water.
  • It meets with Kuroshio warm current 

b. California Current

  • Californian current is flowing towards south along the west coast of U.S.A between 48 N and 23 N latitudes.
  • Has desiccating effect which leads to formation of Mohave and Sonoran desert.

c. Peru Current

  • Peru Current is the best studied ocean current of the Pacific Ocean.
  • Alexander Von Humboldt in 1802 noted the details of the Peru Current. Hence, it is also known as Humboldt Current.
  • It flows north along the west coast of South America carrying cold water  

d. Alaska Current

  • Cold current originating near Alaska and flowing south to meet North Pacific Current

e. West Wind Drift

  • It is an easterly moving drift in the Pacific Ocean extending from Tasmania to the South American coast. It is a cold current.
  • The speed of the drift is greater under the influence of Roaring Forties.

Warm Currents of Pacific Ocean

a. North Equatorial Current

  • North equatorial current originates from Revilla Gigedo island west of Mexico due to trade winds and flows towards the Philippines Island covering a distance of about 12,000 km
  • It gets divided into two and the northern branch joins the Kuroshio Current and the southern branch abruptly turns and forms the Pacific counter current.

b. South Equatorial Current

  • South equatorial current is originated due the action of the trade winds from east to west
  • It is stronger than the North equatorial current.
  • It is further divided into many branches due to the presence of many islands and uneven surface topography.

c. Kuroshio Current

  • Warm ocean current flowing in north easterly direction up to 30 N latitude
  • It meets Oyashio cold current off the Kuril Islands.

d. East Australian Current

  • Warm current flowing southward along the east coast of Australia

Side Note : Japan is good Fishing Ground

  • Warm Kuroshio Current & cold Oyashio Current meets near Southern Japan. Hence, it becomes rich fishing ground.
  • Along with that  Japan has very shallow continental Shelf  leading to  more photic zone and  more marine organisms.
  • Indented coastline of Japan leads  to formation of  natural harbors .
  • Furthermore, Japan is a hilly region with less developed agriculture . Hence, there is main role of fishes in Japanese Diet.
Japan is a good fishing ground

Side Note : Peru Current and Atacama Desert

Peru / Humboldt current is cold current. Hence, it provides desiccating effect to the South American coast leading to formation of Atacama Dessert . Atacama desert is one of the driest places on Earth.

Atacama Desert and Peru Current

Current Topic : Pacific Garbage Patch

Pacific Ocean Garbage Patch is an enormous collection of marine debris (mainly plastic) that is collected and deposited by ocean currents in the middle of the North Pacific Ocean. 

Garbage Patch

Reasons of formation

  • Geographical : Circular motion of the ocean currents draws debris into the center which is calm & stable, where it becomes trapped.
  • Almost 80% of the debris in the Great Pacific Garbage Patch comes from land-based activities in North America and Asia& the remaining 20% from boaters, offshore oil rigs, and large cargo ships. The amount of debris in the patch accumulates since most of it is non-biodegradable, mainly microplastics.

Impact

  • Destruction of marine life due to ingestion of toxic and harmful substances .
  • These toxic substances also enters the food chain resulting in biomagnification
  • Presence of the garbage blocks the sunlight from reaching the planktons and algae, thereby reducing productivity of marine ecosystem.
  • It affects the free flow of traffic through oceans.
  • Impacts the tourism and economic livelihood of small Pacific Ocean island countries 

2.3 Currents in Indian Ocean

Current system in Indian Ocean is unique & different from other current systems .

Indian Ocean Currents in Summer
Indian Ocean Currents in Winter

Why it is different than other currents?

  • In northern hemisphere, it is confined to tropical zone only & that too is divided by Indian peninsula to form Arabian sea & Bay of Bengal.
  • Complete reversal in  direction of winds as monsoon winds also impacts the movement of current.

(wind is important factor – direction in which winds flow determine direction of currents ).

Side Note : Navigation in Indian Ocean.

  • In Summer ,   Wind & current flows toward India . Hence, sea vessel can move from Arabia to India .
  • In Winter,  Wind & current flows toward Arabia . Hence, sea vessel can move from India to Arabia .

Important for sea trade & cultural interaction since Ancient times.

Significance of Ocean Currents

  • Ocean Currents play an important role in earth’s climate by distributing the energy within the ocean. Along with that, they impact the local climate as
    • Warm ocean current increases the temperature of an area
    • Cold ocean current decreases the temperature of an area.
  • Currents also effect the amount of rainfall.
    • Warm water currents increase the rainfall because they bring winds along with them, laden with water vapours.  North America, Ireland, Britain and south India receive rainfall because of this process.
    • On the other hand Atacama desert remains dry because cold water currents don’t play any role in occurrence of rainfall.  Due to this various deserts are situated on the western coast of Australia, South America and Africa.
  • Currents helps in free navigation navigation as Norweigian Current keeps ports of Scandinavia navigable throughout the year and Kuroshio Current keeps ports of Japan navigable during winter.
  • Conjugation of warm and cold water currents helps in increasing the development rate of ‘Plankton’, which is a diet of fish.  This conjugation takes place of eastern coast near New Found land in North America, Bahia Blanca in South America, Japan coast in Asia etc. But on the  other hand conjugation of currents forms dense fog which creates problem for marine navigation. Sometimes ships are not able to move because of this fog.  This whole situation effects the economic activities of respective areas.

3. Vertical Motion of Ocean Water : Upwelling & Downwelling

Vertical circulation of ocean water takes place due to difference in salinity and temperature between the surface and the water deep below.

Upwelling

Upwelling is an oceanographic phenomenon that involves movement of dense, cooler, and usually nutrient-rich water towards the ocean surface, replacing the warmer, usually nutrient-depleted surface water.

UPWELLING & FISHING

  • Cool & nutrient rich water come at surface.
  • Phytoplankton reproduce rapidly in this condition => Consequently, fishes  increase as well.
  • All Upwelling Regions in World  are  good fishing ground. Eg : Canaries, Benguela and Peru Coast
Upwelling regions with good fishing grounds

Downwelling

  • Down welling is the process of accumulation and sinking of cold high saline water beneath warmer or fresher water.
  • Not good for fishing .

4. Vertical Movement : Tides

What are tides

  • Rhythmic rise & fall in level of  ocean  water.

Causes of tide formations (Prelims-2015) .

  • Moon’s gravitational pull is the most important factor.
  • Sun’s gravitational pull ( although not as prominent factor as Moon’ pull but still a major factor)
  • Centrifugal force due to earth’s rotation ( mainly responsible for causing bulges).

On the side of Earth facing the moon , a tidal bulge occurs while on the opposite side although the gravitational attraction of the moon is less as it is farther away, the centrifugal force causes tidal bulge on the other side 

Stages of Tides

Stage I Sea level rises over several hours & cover the intertidal zone –  flood tide.
Stage II Water rises to highest level –  high tide.
Stage III Sea level falls over several hours revealing intertidal zone – ebb tide.
Stage IV Water level stops falling – low tide.

Syzygy

  • Alignment of three or more celestial bodies of same gravitational system in a line.
  • Effects tides in form of variation between high tides & low tides.

a. Spring tide

  • Sun , moon & earth are in line.
  • Occur on full moon or new moon (no moon day)
  • When there is greatest variation between high tide & low tide .
  • High tide is higher than normal high tide & low tide is lower than normal low tide.

b. Neap tide

  • Sun , Earth & Moon are at right angle.
  • Occur when moon is at quarter phase.
  • High tide lower than normal high tide & low tide higher than normal low tides.
Spring and Neap Tide

Daily frequency of Tides

Earth rotates  & moon revolve in same direction,  hence in relative term wrt to moon earth take 24 hrs & 52 minutes to complete one rotation.

  • 2 high tides & two low tides in a day (24.52 hours to be exact)=Semidiurnal
  • Most enclosed water bodies & bodies away from open ocean experience only one high & one low tide .

Tidal Current

  • Movement of ocean water as a result of tidal action is known as a tidal current.
  • In places of narrow coastal inlet these tidal currents flow rapidly through the mouth with greater height and velocity. For example in the Bay of Fundy, between Nova Scotia and New Brunswick of Canada, the difference between high and low tides is as high as 14m. Ports which utilize the tidal current for entry and exit of ships from the harbour are known as tidal ports.

Importance of Tides

  • Creates inter-tidal regions which have special ecology of their own. Eg : Sunderbans
  • Since tides are caused by the earth-moon-sun positions which are known accurately, the tides can be predicted well in advance. This helps the navigators and fishermen plan their activities. Tidal flows are of great importance in navigation.
  • Tidal heights are very important, especially near rivers and within estuaries having shallow ‘bars’ at the entrance, which helps ships and boats in entering into the harbour.
  • Tides are also helpful in desilting the sediments and in removing polluted water from river estuaries.
  • Tides are used to generate electrical power (in Canada, France, Russia, and  China). A 3 MW tidal power project at Durgaduani in Sunderbans of West Bengal is under way.

5. Thermo-Haline Circulations

  • Circulation because of the temperature & salinity of the ocean.
  • Main driving force is freezing of water at Atlantic and salinity .

Sequence

  • First of all water goes to Polar Region ( Atlantic) . It interacts with the land which is very cold and freeze . When water freezes, it will increase the salinity of sub-surface water (because salt separates from water before freezing) .
  • Subsurface water will become dense and goes further down. Consequently, it starts to flow as sub-surface cold current. It will come to South Atlantic ocean and from there to Indian and Pacific Ocean till the Bering Strait where it upwells .
  • Then surface water starts to flow back .

Note : This process is very slow and time frame between downwelling and upwelling can take upto thousand years .

Impact of Climate Warming on this

  • Due to climate change , more fresh water is being added in Atlantic . This will reduce the salinity which is the driving force behind whole process.
  • Hence, climate change and global warming will negatively impact this circulation

Relief features of Ocean

Table of Contents

Relief features of Ocean

This article deals with ‘Oceanography: Relief features of Ocean.’ This is part of our series on ‘Geography’ which is important pillar of GS-1 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Introduction

Hydrosphere covers 70% part of Earth surface and is one of most important Spheres for various living organisms and vegetation. Of the hydrosphere, 97.2% of water on Earth is present in Oceans.

The oceans, unlike the continents, merge so naturally into one another that it is hard to demarcate them. The geographers have divided the oceanic part of the earth into five oceans, namely the Pacific, the Atlantic, the Indian, Southern ocean and the Arctic. The various seas, bays, gulfs and other inlets are parts of these four large oceans.

Oceanic Crust

  • Oceanic Crust is the most fundamental crust.
  • It is Basaltic in nature .        
  • Oceanic crust is more denser & darker  than Continental Crust.
  • Age of continental shelfs is 1 billion year, oceanic crust is younger & nowhere aged more than 200 million years .
  • Deepest point in ocean is Mariana Trench (in Pacific ocean near Northern Mariana Islands with depth 10,971 m )
  • Oceanic Crust is created at Mid Oceanic Ridge & destroyed at Trenches.
  • Ocean floor is not flat & more diverse than continents & quite different from continental ones.
  • Oceans consist of  71% of earth’s crust. 

Division of Ocean

To study ocean bottom properly it should be divided into two divisions

  • Ocean Continent Margin.
  • Deep Ocean Plains.

1 . Ocean Continent Margin

Ocean Continent Margin

Meeting point of ocean & continental crust . It can be divided into three parts.

  • Coast / Coastal Plain
  • Continental Shelf
  • Continental Slope
  • Continental Rise

1 . 1 Coast

Coast can be of two types

  • Submergent Coast : Estuarine , Ria , Fiord and Dalmatian
  • Emergent Coast

1 . 1 . 1 Submergent Coast

a. Fiord

  • Initially mountains are perpendicular to the coast . Glaciers come down to the coast forming u-shaped valley submerging the area. Hence, coastline which was initially straight becomes indented
  • Eg  : Norwegian Coast
Fiord

b. Ria

  • If valleys were submerged by rivers (instead of Glaciers) , it is called Ria
  • Eg : South Hampton, Wales, British Isles etc

c. Dalmatian

  • If mountains are parallel to the coast (instead of perpendicular)
  • If ships are entering this coast, they face barriers
  • Eg : Adriatic Coast (Italy)
Dalmatian

d. Estuary

  • If normal low land region (not mountainous) is submerged at the mouth of river .
  • Eg : Thames, Buenos Aires

1 . 1.2 Emergent Coast

a. Lowland Emergence

  • It usually results in lagoon, salt marshes, long beaches
  • Eg : Eastern Coast of India

b. Emergent Upland Coast

  • No natural harbors are found here
  • Eg : Scotland

1 . 2 Continental Shelf

Continental Shelf
  • Continental shelf is the seaward extension of land that lies under the sea water. It occupies 7% of the sea floor.
  • It is quite shallow (approx 200m ).
  • Region is called PHOTIC REGION ie receives large amount of sunlight . Marine organisms are found here (all floating planktons  , benthos(crabs) & nektons(fishes)).
  • It has gentle slope with an average gradient of 1° or even less. The shelf typically ends at a very steep slope, called the shelf break.
  • Width varies – The shelves are almost absent or very narrow along some of the margins like the coasts of Chile, the west coast of Sumatra, etc. On the contrary, the Siberian shelf in the Arctic Ocean, the largest in the world, stretches to 1,500 km in width . (average width is 80 km)
  • The depth of the shelves also varies. It may be as shallow as 30 m in some areas while in some areas it is as deep as 600 m (Less depth means it will have more photic zone).
  • Made up of Granite rock ( because it is part of continental crust).
  • The continental shelves are covered with variable thicknesses of terrigenous sediments brought down by rivers, glaciers, wind, from the land and distributed by waves and currents. Massive sedimentary deposits received over a long time by the continental shelves, become the source of fossil fuels.

Continental shelves are well known for oil, natural gas, mineral deposits, sulphur, marine fishery  etc. Large number of resources are found in continental Shelf.

a. Petroleum

  • 90% of petroleum reserves of world are found on continental shelves.
  • Because petroleum is formed from submergence of marine living organisms which get converted to petroleum under high temperature & pressure (marine organisms like fish etc are maximum on Continental Shelf because of Photic Zone)
  • Examples : Bombay High, Gulf of Cambay, Persian Gulf, North Sea, Barents Sea(Russia) , Gulf of Mexico, Norwegian Sea  .

b. Sulphur

  • Rarely found on land .
  • Available in sea because of  marine volcanism .
  • Gulf of Mexico is rich source of Sulphur.

c. Placer Deposit

  • Wave action erode beach rocks but there are some materials in rock which don’t disintegrate easily . Disintegrated  material of lower weight is moved very swiftly by waves but  heavy non-disintegrated material keeps on concentrating on shelf . These are called Placer Deposit.
  • Example are as follows
    1. Monazite Sand found on Kerala Coast which is source of Thorium . It is important for  Indian Nuclear Program
    2. Gold in Alaska .
    3. Zircon on coast of Brazil & Australia.
    4. Diamond on South African Coast .

d. Calcium

  • Least soluble in ocean water & can be easily extracted  .
  • Peruvian coast  is rich in Calcium & Phosphate .

e. Fishes

  • Due to photic zone and availability of planktons , fishes are also found in the wasters of Continental Shelf.
  • World famous fishing grounds like Grand Bank are situated here

f. Pearls

  • Pearls of ornamental value are also found here.

Side Topic : Sea Boundaries (under UNCLOS)

Territorial Sea 
(12 nautical miles 
from baseline) 
Land 
Exclusive Economic Zone 
(up to 200 naut. miles from baseline) 
Contiguous Zone 
(up to 12 miles) 
Continental Shelf 
High Sea 
Area 
(deep sea bed)

a. Internal waters

  • All the water that is inside the coastline is called Internal Waters
  • State has complete sovereignty over this and  it is equivalent to territory of country

b. Territorial Sea

  • Upto 12 Nautical Miles (1 NM = 1.85 Km)  (provided there is no other country on the other side. If any other country is present, it becomes midway)
  • Here too almost all of the laws of the land apply. It is almost as good as territory
  • Vessel of any other nation need permission to enter into territorial waters of other country & submarine has to come on surface & declare its identity while navigation .

c. Contiguous Zone

  • Upto 24 Nautical Miles .
  • Some dilution of political laws
  • Navy & Coast Guard cant guard this but if criminals like smugglers after  doing some crime try to run then that country can follow them till this point .

d. Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)

  • Upto 200 Nautical Miles.
  • All the economic laws of country apply but political laws don’t apply here
  • Country can explore both biotic and abiotic resources of the water and ocean floor .
  • Other countries have right to peaceful passage .

Exceptional Case

  • If Continental shelf is beyond 200 Nautical Miles , country can claim EEZ upto that point with maximum limit of 350 NM
  • Within this extended zone, state has exclusive right of exploiting and exploring non-living resources of the sea bed as well as sedentry species on the sea bed. Fishing rights arent inclusive in 200 to 350 Nautical Miles.
Arabian 
Not to scale 
650E 
700 
INDIA 
Indian Ocean 
750 
B of 
engal 
850 
250 
200 
150 
100 
950 
INDIA 
SRI 
LANKA 
0 OTER LIMIT 
North Indian Ocean with Arabian Sea and Bay of Bengal dashed Lines 
demacrate India's EEZ Which covers about 2 million sq,km, Which is roughly 
60% of India's land area.lndia's coastline including islands is about 7000 km long.

d. International waters / High Sea

  • Beyond EEZ
  • Here resources belong to everyone. No nation has sovereign rights over this area.

Side Topic : Nautical Mile

  • It is the distance per one minute of latitude (1/60th of 1 degree) 
  • 1 Nautical Mile = 1.85 Km

 (1.85*60=111 Km = Distance covered per degree latitude . )

At equator, 1 degree of longitude is also 111 km . But this distance keep on reducing while going North and South and is 0 at poles . But distance between latitudes is always same (because they are parallel) and is 111 km approx at every point

1 . 3 Continental Slope

  • The zone of steep slope extending from the continental shelf to the deep sea plain or abyssal plain is called continental slope.
  • It has very steep slope .The slope angle varies from 5° to 60°.
  • No deposition is possible because of steep slope . Hence,  no resources are  found in this zone. 
  • But some unique landforms are created specially when there is mouth of very large river at continental shelf like  Indus, Ganga, Mississippi, Yukon & Congo. Example of such landform are
    • SUBMARINE CANYONS in which flow of water would be so great that it will vertically erode both continental shelf & slope . In Indian Ocean, submarine canyons are found at mouths of river Ganga and Indus.
    • Underwater Waterfalls – Highest waterfall on earth is under the Denmark strait.
Continental Slope

1 . 4 Continental Rise

  • Transition between Continental Slope & Sea Floor.
  • There would be no continental rise in case there is TRENCH after Continental slope  .

2 . Deep Ocean Plains

Major portion of Ocean Crust consist of Deep Ocean Plains which have various relief features like Mid Ocean Ridge, Islands, Guyots etc. These are as follows :-

Deep Ocean Plains

2 . 1 Abyssal/ Deep Sea Plains

  • Occupies 40% of ocean floor.
  • Consists older parts of oceanic crust that are smoothened due to sediment deposition. 
  • Among flattest, smoothest & least explored regions of earth.
  • Average depth varies from 3000 to 6000 metres  .
  • It has deposits from continents( terrigenous), marine life(biogenous) & salts and minerals(inorganic).
  • Abyssal plains of Southern Indian Ocean and Eastern Pacific Ocean are rich sources of Poly Metallic Nodules.
Abyssal Plains

Side Topic : Poly-Metallic Nodules (PMN)

  • Polymetallic Nodules (AKA Manganese Nodules) .
  • Multiple metals are concentrated around core .
  • Found at depth of around 4,000 to 6,000 m on the floor
  • Were first found around Kara Sea & Arctic sea but later nodules were found in all oceans .
  • But are economically viable to extract only in Central Indian Ocean & Eastern Pacific Ocean.
  • Composition : Manganese (Highest) and apart from this contain Iron , Silicon, Al, Nickel & Cobalt & some  rare metals.
  • Important for India as India doesn’t have good source of Nickel & Cobalt .
  • Countries are  in race to explore & extract PMN.

2. 2 Islands

An island is a landmass surrounded by water on all sides.

They are of four types

a. Continental Island

  • Once part of large continent.
  • Examples : Sri Lanka, Madagascar, Vancouver, Baffin islands.
  • Note : Madagascar Island  formed after separation from Indo- Australian Plate
  • Generally bigger in size than all other categories of Islands.
  • Rock composition and all of continental island is same as plate from which it is separated .

b. Volcanic Island

  • Ocean – Ocean plate collision or  Hotspot  activity.
  • Examples : Andaman & Nicobar Islands, Japan, Philippines, Kurile, Aleutian Islands, Hawaii etc

c. Coral Island

  • Marine organisms, the coral polyps colonize the tropical warm water and form islands known as coral islands. 
  • Examples include Lakshadweep, Maldives, Mauritius, Bahama & Bermuda

d. Sandbar Island

  • Formed by accumulation of sand near coast => Sand which is eroded from main land is again settled near coast & if continental shelf is shallow nearby then sandbar island is formed .
  • Example : Long Island (New York)

Side Topic : Archipelago

  • Cluster of islands  .
  • (GK) Largest archipelago.
By area Indonesia
By number of islands Finland

2.3 Coral Reefs

  • Corals are indicative of health of Marine Ecosystem ie  if coral reef exists at any place in healthy way , entire ecosystem is healthy.
  • Wherever there is coral reef , you will find great biodiversity at that point.
  • Most diverse ecosystem of world => 10% area but 25% marine species . They can be said to be Rain Forests of the Ocean.
Corals

What are corals?

  • Corals are tiny fleshy Sea Anemones Polyps.
  • They extract Calcium from sea water for their skeletons to protect their body.When one generation die other generation comes on it.
  • Corals live in symbiotic relationship with microscopic algae- Zoo-xanthalae which have photosynthesis capabilities.
  • Zoo-xanthalae provide food to corals and corals provide protection to zooxanthalae.

Conditions conducive for  corals 

  • Water  temperature  in  the  range  of    22-29  degrees  Celsius.  Thus,  areal  distribution  of  corals  is  limited to  tropical  and  sub-tropical  zones. 
  • They  will  not  flourish  in  areas  of  cold  currents  but  thrive  in  warm current  regions.  Therefore,  they  are  generally  absent  on  western  coasts  of  continents.  
  • Depth  of  water  should  not  exceed  180  feet  as  the  sunlight  is  too  faint  for  photosynthesis  which  is essential  for  survival  of  microscopic  Zoo-xanthalae  on  which  coral  polyps  depend.  However,  there  should  be plenty  of  water  as polyps cannot  survive for  too long  out  of  water.
  • Water should  be  salty  and  free  of  sediments.  Corals  are  best  developed  on  seaward  side  of  reef,  where constantly  moving  waves, tides  and currents maintain  an abundant  supply  of  clear, oxygenated water

Spatial Distribution of corals in the world

Spatial Distribution of corals in the world

Spatial distribution of Corals in India

In India they are found in

  • Gulf of Mannar.
  • Andaman &Nicobar
  • Lakshadweep
  • Gulf of Kutch
  • Sindudurg coast ( near Malvan Coast) in Maharashtra  ( only here in India, bleaching hasn’t happened yet)

While the Lakshadweep reefs are atolls, the others are all fringing reefs.

AFGHANISTAN 
PAKISTAN 
Gulf Of Kut 
Sindudurg 
CHINA 
N EPAL 
BHUTAN 
ANGLADEsH 
INDIA 
civilspedia.com @ 
MYANMAR 
oast 
Andaman and 
Nicobar 
If of Mannar 
Lakshadweep 
LAN

Coral Bleaching

  • When corals are in stress they expel Zoo-xanthalae.
  • Zoo-xanthalae give the colourful appearance to corals . In their absence, corals seems white (their original colour) .
  • Ultimately without food corals will die out too.

Reasons of coral Bleaching

  1. Global Warming : increase in sea surface temperature .
  2. Ozone Depletion : increase in solar irradiation.
  3. Ocean Acidification : because of increase in Carbon Dioxide in atmosphere . This Carbon Dioxide dissolves in ocean water & water becomes acidic . Corals can’t live in acidic water
  4. Algal Bloom : excessive use of fertilisers go to ocean through rivers resulting in Algal Bloom . Sunlight cant go below & corals die.
  5. Increase in sedimentation from rivers.
  6. Marine pollution like oil spills . No sunlight & oxygen reach below.
  7. Diseases.
  8. Coastal construction and shoreline development: Results in heavy sedimentation
  9. Coral mining: Live coral is removed from reefs for use as bricks etc.

Consequences of Coral Bleaching

  • It will impact marine ecosystem, as coral reefs are some of the most bio diverse and productive ecosystems.
  • Reefs act as natural barriers to shorelines, protecting them from the effects of moving water. As coral reefs die, coastlines become more susceptible to damage and flooding from storms, hurricanes, and cyclones.
  • Ocean will not be able to absorb as much Carbon Dioxide because Zoo-xanthalae absorb Carbon Dioxide for photosynthesis leading to increased Global Warming.

Measures need to be taken

  • Political measures: The global agreements combating climate change must keep the needs of coral islands as top priority.
  • Switching to sustainable livelihood measures: It is high time to recognize the carrying capacity of each coral island ecosystem and limit population growth, tourist foot fall etc. at these islands.
  • Sustainable development : Avoid major projects in threatened areas. Eg : Carmichael Coal Mine in Australia that threatens Great Barrier Reef should be avoided.

Formation of Coral Reef

Coral Reef can be developed both at margins of continents or around islands  .

3 stages of coral formation are as follows

First Stage 
leading to formation of 
Fringing Reef 
Second Stage 
Substantial submersion of 
island + formation of 
Lagoon 
Last Stage 
leading to formation of 
Atoll => Island fully 
submerges 
Fringing Reef 
Barrier Reef 
Atoll 
goon

Stage 1 : Fringing

  • Coral reef  starts to develop along margin of an island & subduction of island just starts
  • First stage of Fringing Reef

Stage 2 : Barrier Reef

  • Corals keep on accumulating and keep on rising  upwards. As a result, large part of island is submerged in sea/ocean.
  • Lagoon formation occurs

Stage 3 : Atoll

  • Last Stage
  • Island is submerged & only ring remains visible . 

Note : In India, while the Lakshadweep reefs are atolls, the others are all fringing reefs.

Side Topic : Great Barrier Reef , Australia

  • Adani’s are investing in Coal Fields in Australia (Carmichael Coal Fields) . Project will create jobs for Australians and coal will be imported to India
  • But due to large Carbon-dioxide emissions in the area  , Great Barrier Reef will be impacted heavily.
Great Barrier Reef and Carmichael Coal Field

2.4 Oceanic Trench/ Oceanic Deep

  • The long, narrow, steep-sided depressions formed  along the convergent boundary where one plate subducts below the other is  called Ocean trenches. 
  • The Challenger Deep in the Mariana Trench, (10,994 m) in the Pacific Ocean is the deepest part of the earth.
  • Most trenches are in Pacific ocean & they are most active  geological feature. Great earthquakes leading to Tsunamis occur here.
  • As many as 57 deeps have been explored so far; of which 32 are in the Pacific Ocean; 19 in the Atlantic Ocean and 6 in the Indian Ocean.
Trenches

Main Trenches of the world

Main Trenches of the world

2.5 Seamounts / Guyots  

  • Flat topped volcanic hills submerged under the sea water are called guyots.
  • Seamounts are conical, volcanic hills submerged under ocean water
  • Seamounts , guyots  and the water column above them serve as important habitats, feeding grounds and sites of reproduction for many open-ocean and deep-sea species.
Guyot Seamounts

2.6 Abyssal Fans

  • Also known as Deep Sea Fans or Underwater Deltas or Submarine Fans .
  • Delta like structure formed at  deep sea surfaces . Major reservoirs of biodiversity.
Abyssal Fans

2.7 Mid Oceanic Ridge

  • Mid-ocean ridges are submarine mountains.
  • Mid oceanic ridges are located on the divergent plate boundaries where magma flows through the fissure to form new oceanic crust. They form the longest mountain range in the world extending for more than 56,000 km long.
Mid Oceanic Ridge

Issue of Poverty

Last Updated: March 2024 (Issue of Poverty)

Issue of Poverty

This article deals with the Issue of Poverty.’ This is part of our series on ‘Governance’ and ‘Economics’ series, which is an important pillar of the GS-2 and GS-3 syllabus respectively. For more articles, you can click here.


Poverty is the worst form of violence- GANDHI

Introduction

What is Poverty?

Poverty is a social concept which results due to unequal distribution of benefits of socio-economic progress.


How does it manifest itself?

Poverty manifests itself in the following ways

  • Hunger & Malnutrition
  • Lack of access to education and health care
  • Social Discrimination
  • Lack of participation in decision making

World Bank definition

World Bank defines extreme and moderate poverty in the following way

Extreme poverty Living on less than $ 1.25 per day.
Moderate poverty Living on less than $ 2 per day.

Note – Poverty is measured in Purchasing Power Parity(PPP) exchange rate & not absolute exchange rate.

A recent World Bank Report has shown that extreme poverty in India more than halved between 2011 and 2019 – from 22.5 per cent to 10.2 percent. 


Poverty Gap

Poverty Gap
  • It measures the Depth of poverty
  • It is also called Foster-Greer-Thorbecke (FGT) Index.

Engel’s Law

Engel Law states that when incomes rises, percentage of overall income spent on food items decreases. This is known as ENGEL’S LAW.

Engel's Law
Engel's Law

SDG & Poverty

  • Sustainable Development Goals gives utmost importance to poverty. The First SDG talks about ending poverty in all its forms everywhere by 2030.
SDG 1: End Poverty in all its forms everywhere by 2030
  • India is home to 26% of the global extreme poor. Hence, the Indian role in achieving that goal is most important.

Causes of Poverty

Economic Reason

  • Growth Model not conducive to poverty alleviation: India chose a capital-intensive model in a labour-intensive country, which was a great fault. 
  • Widespread reliance on agriculture (42% population is dependent on sector contributing 17% to the GDP)
  • Lack of formal institutional credit pushes a large number of Indians into poverty every year.
  • MATTHEW EFFECT:  The phenomenon, widely spread across advanced welfare states that the middle class tends to be the primary beneficiary of social benefits & services targeted to the poor (India is trying to rectify this using Targeted Delivery of Subsidy with the help of Jan Dhan-Aadhar-Mobile).   

Demographic Factors

  • Rapid Population growth in India is also the primary cause of poverty as enough resources were not available for all.

Social Cause

  • Caste system: The subordination of low caste people by the high caste people caused poverty of the former.
  • Joint family system: Joint Family System, followed by many families in India, provides social security to its members. As a result, some people take undue advantage of it and live upon the income of others. They become idlers. Their routine of life consists in eating, sleeping and begetting children.
  • Social Customs: Ruralites spend a large percentage of annual earnings on social ceremonies like marriage, death feasts etc., which force them to take debt and remain trapped in poverty.

Climatic Factors

  • Drought, Floods, Cyclones etc. perpetuate poverty.

Historical Factors

  • Historical reasons such as colonialism & imperialism led to the exploitation of Indian people. India’s wealth was drained to metropole Britain for two centuries. 

Institutional Factors

  • Withdrawal of Government from Social Security, especially after LPG Reforms.
  • Anti-poverty schemes are not successfully implemented due to institutional inadequacies.

Poverty Line

What is Poverty Line?

  • The poverty line is the threshold income and households earning below this threshold are considered poor. 
  • Different countries define the poverty line in different ways depending on local socio-economic needs.

Different approaches to define the poverty line

There are two approaches regarding this 

  1. Nutritional Approach: It is based on specific minimum criteria of nutrition intake 
  2. Relative Deprivation Approach: It doesn’t take into account just nutritional deficits, but in comparison to the progressive section, the person is not that progressed. E.g., a person earning less than 60% of the country’s per capita income

Developing countries generally follow the nutritional Approach. But now the time has come that India should move from the Nutritional Approach to the Relative Deprivation Approach to ensure sustainable and equitable development.


Poverty line in India is decided by

  • Earlier it was used to be determined by erstwhile Planning Commission
  • Now NITI Aayog determines the Poverty Line. NITI Aayog made the Commission under Arvind Panagariya recommend Poverty Line in India.
  • Panagariya has suggested that 
    • Tendulkar Committee’s report should be accepted for poverty line estimation. 
    • But socio-economic indicators, say, as collected by Socio-Economic Caste Census, should be used to determine entitlement for benefits.

Various Committees constituted for Poverty Line Determination

Timeline of Committees to define Poverty

1. Lakdawala Committee

In books, we frequently come across the Poverty Line defined as 2400 calories in Rural & 2100 calories in Urban. This definition of the Poverty Line was based on the recommendations of the Lakdawala Committee (1999). 


2. Tendulkar Committee

Tendulkar Committee defined Poverty Line based on per capita monthly expenditure.

Tendulkar Committee

While calculating, Tendulkar Committee based its recommendation on food, health, education and clothing.

Tendulkar Committee for Poverty

According to Tendulkar Committee Report, Poverty has declined in India from 37.2% in 2004 to 22% in 2011.

Number of people below Poverty Line

3. C Rangarajan Committee

C Rangarajan Committee defined Poverty Line based on Monthly Expenditure of family of five.

Rangarajan Committee

Rangarajan Committee took more things than Tendulkar Committee into its calculations

Rangarajan Committee for Poverty

Rangarajan Committee also recommended delinking the Poverty line from the Government entitlement benefits. Food Security benefits should be given as per Social and Caste dimensions and not BPL. 


4. Saxena Committee on Rural Poverty (2009)

  • When Tendulkar Committee Report came, the Ministry of Rural development hurriedly set up a committee known as the SAXENA COMMITTEE in 2009 to review the methodology for inclusion of a person in the BPL Category to include them in government schemes. 

Recommendation of the Committee

Committee gave the famous Automatic Inclusion and Automatic Exclusion principle.

  • The automatic inclusion criterion for the most vulnerable sections of society (E.g. homeless people, persons with disabilities etc.)
  • Automatic Exclusion: Those having motorbikes etc. 
  • Apart from being Automatically included, find other using scores of various deprivations. 

5. Hashim Committee on Urban Poverty (2012)

  • To suggest a methodology for inclusion of a person in the BPL category in Urban Areas to include them in government schemes.

Recommendations of the Committee 

  • Automatic Exclusion 
  • Automatic Inclusion 
  • Scoring Index: remaining households will be assigned scores from 0 to 12 based on various indicators. They should be considered eligible for inclusion in the BPL List in the increasing order of higher scores.  

Multidimensional Poverty Index

  • In India, we calculate poverty using Tendulkar Method based on household consumption.
  • But UNDP takes a holistic view of poverty and measure it differently. 
  • The report has been released since 2010.
  • In Multidimensional Poverty, they look into the following components to measure poverty (HES)
    • Health with components like child mortality
    • Education with components like years of schooling
    • Standard of Living with components like Electricity, water etc.
Multidimensional Poverty Index

Andhra Pradesh is already using this approach.


Capability Approach to Poverty by Amartya Sen

Traditional Approach

  • Poverty is defined by an individual’s income
  • E.g., Extreme Poverty is defined as those who live on $1.25 per day or less. 
  • As a result, following this approach, governments centre their Poverty Removal Policies on job creation, GDP growth and other economic policies.

Capability Approach 

  • In richer countries, all are fortunate enough that they can earn a good income. Does that mean they are not poor?
  • Amartya Sen’s Capability approach defines poverty in a Holistic Way. A better approach to look at poverty is the deprivation of a person’s capabilities to live the life they value. 

Well Being Approach

Given by Erik Allard, it includes three dimensions as:

  1. ​Having (Material),
  2. Loving (Social), and
  3. Being (Spiritual-emotional)

World Poverty Clock

  • The World Poverty Clock was developed by World Data Lab to monitor global progress toward ending extreme poverty.
  • The latest data (released in March 2024) shows that India has managed to reduce extreme poverty to below 3% of its population.

Critique of these Poverty Lines

  • Experts argue that the Indian way of calculating poverty is incorrect.  It is simply what some call a “starvation line”. Critics argue that governments around the world keep the poverty line at low levels to show that millions have been moved out of poverty.
  • India should be using some relative measure as opposed to the absolute measure to define poverty. In most Europe, a family with a net income of less than 60% of the “median net disposable income” is counted as poor. A poverty line “relative” to the national average also gives an idea about the state of inequality.  
  • A comparison shows that India’s poverty line is abysmally low than even African Poverty Lines. Even the poverty line of Rwanda is higher than that of India. The per capita poverty line of a rural adult Rwandan in Indian terms comes out to be Rs. 900/ month, more than Rs. 816 for a person in rural India.  
  • Another critique that Poverty Line faces is that once decided, the PL remains the same for years & don’t take into account inflation.  It needs to be updated every year by applying a cost inflation index to keep it realistic.
  • Multidimensional Poverty Index: We define poverty in a minimal way by just looking at household consumption. UNDP defines poverty using the Multidimensional Poverty Index, which takes a holistic view and considers indicators like Health, Education, and Standard of Living. India should move toward that.

Reduction of Poverty in India

According to Tendulkar Committee Report, poverty in India has reduced from 37.2% in 2004 to 22% in 2011.

Poverty Rate in India

Reduction in poverty is attributed to

  1. Increase in employment in the non-agriculture sector – The construction sector absorbed the landless labourers & daily wage earners from villages
  2. Schemes like MGNREGA, National rural livelihood mission also reduced the stress during the lean season by creating employment opportunities during the non-agricultural season.
  3. India’s demographic bulge provided more working population compared to dependents (Children and elders).
  4. Social welfare schemes like PDS, AAY, MGNREGA, NRLM, Pension schemes and others provided a safety net to the poor 
  5. Inward remittances – Large emigration of the citizen to the US, EU etc. and to west Asian destinations like UAE, Saudi, Qatar etc. generated huge inward remittances for India, which directly benefited dependents in India
  6. Quality jobs in the Service sector like BPO, Hospitality, Retail chain, E-commerce supply chain provided heavy wages.
  7. The rapid growth of the economy provided better opportunities to come out of poverty through better employment opportunities, increased demand for services etc.

Chinese Case Study

  • According to World Bank, people living below the poverty line reduced from 770 million in 1978 to 5.5 million in 2019.
  • In 2021, China declared that it had eradicated extreme poverty.
  • Steps taken by Government in this regard
    1. Targeted Approach: China identified the poorest region to allocate more resources there.  
    2. Economic Development: China’s economic development generated a lot of jobs, helping people to come out of poverty
    3. Social Welfare Programs: The government provided healthcare coverage, education, housing assistance etc. 
    4. Agriculture and Rural Development: China focused on agricultural reforms, modernization, and supporting farmers. 


Impact of LPG Reforms on Poverty

  • Poverty has decreased: Consider any Poverty Line, all points to the fact that Poverty in India has declined. Take the example of the extreme poverty line as defined by the World Bank.
Poverty in India and LPG Reforms
  • Inequality: Inequality in India has increased after LPG Reforms.
Inequality and LPG Reforms

The rich section has reaped the benefits of LPG Reforms. This is the leading cause of the increase in Inequality.

The above Paradox can be explained by the Redistribution of Income by Government. Because of the increase in income of richer sections, the government is getting more taxes. Therefore, redistribution of this source has ensured that Poverty has decreased.


Impact of Poverty

Several issues like hunger, illness and thirst are both causes and effects of poverty. Hence, the term known as poverty trap is usually used for this i.e. bad cycle is created not allowing people to come out of poverty

Poverty Trap
On Society Poverty results in inequalities which can culminate into violent upheavals like Arab Spring. Various Revolutions in Arab Spring started because of the lack of jobs and high poverty levels.    
On Children Poverty leads children to build antisocial behaviour and social exclusion.    
Terrorism Most of the time terrorists do come from poor countries with high unemployment.  
Diseases Diseases are very common in people living in poverty because they lack the resources to maintain a healthy living environment.   
Education Those living below the poverty line cannot attend schools and create a vicious cycle in which poverty prevents people from getting a good education, and being uneducated prevents them from escaping poverty.  
Poverty Trap

How can India reduce poverty?

Even though India has grown rapidly, its growth has been less effective at reducing poverty than in some of India’s middle-income peers such as China, Vietnam, Brazil and Turkey. The following can be done in this respect.


In Agricultural sector

With 4 out of every 5 of India’s poor living in rural areas, progress will need to focus on the rural poor. Hence, the government should focus on following to increase the income of those involved in the agriculture sector.

  • Value addition through food processing 
  • Organic farming  
  • Cooperation farming, milk cooperatives, and farmer producer organizations. 

In Manufacturing Sector

Create Jobs in India via

  • Skill development
  • Make in India
  • Startup India

In Service Sector

  • Creation of quality jobs in BPO, IT and ITES for youth 
  • Promotion of tourism
  • Promotion of higher job creation in e-commerce, supply chain, Hospitality and construction sectors.

In Governance

  • Implement Jan Dhan- Aadhar- Mobile (JAM) effectively to target subsidy to the poor and eliminate inclusion and exclusion errors.
  • Look into the feasibility of providing Universal Basic Income. 

Pressure Groups

Pressure Groups

Pressure Groups

This article deals with ‘Pressure Groups.’ This is part of our series on ‘Governance’ which is important pillar of GS-2 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here


What are Pressure Groups?

  • Pressure Groups are groups of people trying to pressurize the administrative-political system to protect and promote their interests. 
  • These groups operate outside formal governmental structures and focus on specific issues or causes.

How & why they were born in India?

Market Economy

  • In the market economy, there is a struggle over tax/tariffs and a race to get concessions from the government. Different business groups emerged (e.g. FICCI, ASSOCHAM etc., in India) to pressurize the government to make policies that serve their interests.

Welfare State

  • The government started to look after welfare functions, e.g. reservations in education & jobs.
  • Different groups emerged to safeguard their interests.

Political Angle

  • Politicians set their priorities according to the vote bank because they ultimately need votes to win elections. Hence, politicians will always favour landless labourers and workers because their number is more
  • In this case, Zamindars and Businessmen will try to protect their interests by forming a pressure group because, number-wise, they can’t win. 

Activist Angle

Pressure groups are also formed to protect the rights of people. E.g.,  

  • Narmada Bachao Andolan: To rehabilitate the displaced and protect the environment 
  • Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan in Rajasthan pressurized government to form RTI 

Political Party vs Pressure Group

Political Party vs Pressure Group
Political Party Pressure Group
They are permanent  They are temporary
They have a long-term vision & aim. They are formed on ideological lines, common values and preferences They have short-term & narrow vision. In some cases, they may focus on a single issue (for instance, opposing a planned road development). 
They have cadre based organization  They don’t have any cadre
Eg : BJP, INC, BSP etc. Eg : FICCI, ADR etc.

Type of Pressure Groups

The different types of pressure groups found in India are business groups, trade unions, peasant groups, student groups, teachers’ associations, caste and religious associations, women’s associations, etc.

1. Business Groups

  • Business Groups are the most important and organized pressure groups as they have enough resources to safeguard their interests.  
  • E.g., FICCI and the Associated Chambers of Commerce (ASSOCHAM).  
  • Business Pressure Groups exert pressure via funding parties. 

2. Trade Unions

  • Trade Unions are closely affiliated with political parties 
  • The main weapon of Trade Unions includes strikes and demonstrations.

3. Peasant Organizations

  • Peasant Organizations were present even before independence. But after the abolition of Zamindari & Green Revolution, they became very important. 
  • Examples of Peasant Pressure Groups include All India Kisan Congress, Akhil Bharatiya Kisan Sangh etc. But these peasant groups have been organized on a territorial basis. 
  • Their demands relate to procurement prices, fertilizer subsidies, electricity charges, etc.  

4. Student Organizations

  • Student Organizations are mostly affiliated with political parties. 
  • Examples of Student Pressure Groups include 
    1. National Students Union of India (NSUI) (affiliated with the Congress Party) 
    2. Students Federation of India (SFI) (affiliated with the Communist Party of India) 
    3. Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) (affiliated with BJP)   
  • They try to pressurize governmental policy on various crucial issues and their activities are not just confined to educational issues

5. Community Associations

  • The Community Associations are organized on the basis of caste, class and religion.  
  • These include
    1. Caste Organizations: Scheduled Caste Federation, Backward Caste Federation, etc.  
    2. Religion Organizations: Vishwa Hindu Parishad, Northern and Southern India Christian Conference, etc.   

Interest Groups vs. Cause Groups

Interest Groups 

  • Interest Groups are pressure groups representing a particular interest of society: workers, employers, consumers or religious groups, etc. 
  • Their membership is limited to people of that interest.
  • For example
    1. Trade Unions (like AITUC)
    2. Business Corporations (FICCI and ASSOCHAM)   
    3. Professional Bodies
    4. Regional Groups (like Bajrang Dal)
    5. Caste Groups (like Karni Sena, Jat Mahasangh etc.) 

Cause Groups

  • Cause Groups are based on a certain cause  
  • Causes range from charity, poverty reduction, environment, human rights, transparency in governance etc. 
  • Membership is open to all. Members are motivated by altruistic concerns   
  • For example
    1. Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan: Working for transparency in governance  
    2. PETA: Working for Animal Rights 
    3. India against Corruption: Working to end corruption in India 

Tools and Methods of Functioning of Pressure Groups 

These methods and tools can be broadly divided into following groups

Tools and Methods of Functioning of Pressure Groups

Meetings with Ministers and Civil Servants 

  • Ministers and Civil Servants are the centres of power.
  • Pressure Groups (like FICCI or ASSOCHAM) aspire to get in touch with them to get some sort of concessions.

Lobbying

  • Lobbying is the act of loitering in lobbies of  legislative assembly and influence decisions of law-makers
  • Pressure groups try to take their voice to the Parliament through MPs and MLAs as changes can be brought in details of the acts, and their issues can reach a larger audience through Parliamentary Questions. 

Funding Political Parties

  • All parties need funds to fight elections. Pressure Groups with financial strength can fund the political parties in the hope that they will safeguard their interest if they form their Government.

Direct  Action

  • Pressure groups may resort to direct action methods such as strikes, boycotts, sit-ins, and demonstrations to draw attention to their concerns and compel policymakers to address them. These actions aim to disrupt normal functioning to create pressure for change.

Coalition Building

  • Pressure groups often form alliances and coalitions with like-minded organizations and individuals to amplify their collective strength and impact.

Expert Testimony and Consultations

  • Pressure groups may provide expert testimony and participate in official consultations, committee hearings, and public forums to contribute their specialized knowledge and shape policy debates.

Media Engagement

  • Pressure groups utilize media channels, including print, electronic, and digital media, to disseminate their messages, highlight their concerns, and reach a wider audience. 

Research and Policy Analysis

  • Pressure groups conduct in-depth research and policy analysis to gather evidence, data, and arguments supporting their positions. They may commission studies and publish reports.

Litigation and Legal Advocacy

  • Pressure groups may resort to litigation and legal advocacy to pursue their goals. They file public interest litigations (PILs) in courts to seek judicial intervention and influence policy outcomes through legal means.

Role & Benefits of Pressure Groups

1. Representation to Unrepresented

  • Pressure groups provide voice to groups and interests that are inadequately represented during elections. 
  • For example
    1. Women’s organizations such as Self Employed Women Association (SEWA), NCW etc., worked for the formulation of women-friendly laws like the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act of 2005.  
    2. In the North-Eastern State of Manipur, Pressure groups such as ‘Just Peace‘ and  Meira Paibis (women’s groups)  are trying to influence the Government to listen to people’s genuine grievances.  

2. Policy Formulation

  • Pressure groups in India play a significant role in the policy formulation process.
  • For example
    1. Business Groups like FICCI and ASSOCHAM are consulted by the government while forming Business Policy
    2. Kisan Unions like All India Kisan Congress are consulted by the government while forming agricultural policies 
    3. Students Unions like ABVP, NSUI, AISF etc., are consulted by the government while forming education policies. 

3. Persistent check on the government’s power

  • Elections are held just once in 5 years. In such a situation, these Pressure groups keep a check on the government all the time.
  • In cases where the government oversteps its boundaries or violates the law, pressure groups can take legal action, direct action, or mobilize public opinion.

4. Education

Pressure groups educate people through political debate and discussion. They gather and disseminate information about their cause or issue of concern. E.g., 

  1. Association for Democratic Reforms (ADR) releases reports to educate people on political issues and elections.  
  2. Greenpeace is an environmental pressure group that educates people about environmental issues like pollution, deforestation, and climate change.  
  3. Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) is an organization that advocates for digital rights, internet freedom, and privacy in India and educates people about online surveillance, data privacy, and censorship issues.

5. Other Benefits

  • Ensures pluralism in the representation of interests: In policy-making, you will find a group which demands a complete ban on tobacco to a group of tobacco manufacturers who is the pressurizing government not to implement such policies 

Points against Pressure Groups

Create Political Inequality

  • Instead of dispersing power widely, pressure groups tend to empower the already powerful. Pressure groups often have varying levels of resources, such as funding, expertise, and connections, which can give them greater access to decision-makers and policymakers.

Tyranny of the Minority 

  • Pressure groups aid in preventing the “tyranny of the majority.” However, pressure groups may create the opposite problem, i.e. Tyranny of the Minority.   
  • These groups sometimes ransack the whole state, e.g. Jat Agitation, in which property worth Billions was vandalized. 

Decreases the Legitimacy of the Government

  • When government work under pressure from Pressure groups, the common public loses trust in the government.

Behind the Scenes’ influence

  • Due to this, the governance lacks transparency and accountability.

Comparison of Indian and Western Pressure Groups

  • The pressure groups in the USA are regarded as the fourth organ of the government, while the Indian pressure groups are not yet able to play the same substantial role.
  • In India and Great Britain, Pressure Groups target cabinet and civil service. However, the targets of American pressure groups are Congress and its committees.   
  • Indian pressure groups based on caste, religion, region, etc., are more powerful than modern groups like business organizations which are powerful in Western nations.
  • In the USA, pressure groups are interested in foreign policy issues, while in India,  pressure groups are concerned more with domestic policy issues and problems.

MNREGA

MNREGA

This article deals with ‘MNREGA.’ This is part of our series on ‘Governance’ which is important pillar of GS-2 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Introduction

  • Government as an employer of the last resort is an idea that has existed since Great Depression in United States.
  • However, MGNREGA takes this policy to a new realm because of its massive reach, universal nature, and its initiation during a period of rapid economic growth.

About Program (prelims)

  • MGNREGA = Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (2005)
  • Under Ministry of Rural Development
  • Provides a legal guarantee for 100 days of employment  to adult member of any rural household willing to do unskilled manual work
  • It is demand driven scheme (not supply driven)
  • Wages are to be paid according to the Minimum Wages Act 1948 for agricultural labourers . Equal wages will be provided to both men and women.
  • 60:40 wage and material ratio has to be maintained ( labour-intensive nature of the scheme)
  • Central Govt pays  100 percent wage cost of manual labour & 75 percent of the material cost
  • Social Audit has to be done by the Gram Sabha (legal provision).

Achievements of MNREGA

  • Revitalization of Rural Labour Markets : Poor workers have got bargaining power to demand higher wages .
  • Women : Women are getting work as right leading to their emancipation  (dealt separately).
  • Sustainable Assets in water harvesting created especially in states like Bihar , Gujarat, Rajasthan etc . This also led to increase in agro productivity .
  • Hundreds of bonded labour (Saheriya Adivasis) in Rajasthan freed from generations of bondage. 
  • MGNREGA has reduced distress migration.
  • Has shown some unintended benefits => Banks account opened by poor workers because wages were paid through  banks (Financial Inclusion).
  • Empowering Gram Panchayats :  act gave gram Sabhas the mandate to plan their own works and untied funds to execute these works. No other scheme has placed funds at this scale (Rs 15 lakh per year on average) directly with Gram Panchayats.
  • MGNREGA has served as an important shock absorber for the rural economy by providing an important relief in times of distress eg distress situation created by drought .

Criticism

  • Corruption : workers not paid in full or forced to pay bribes to get jobs + ghost workers
  • Poor Quality Infrastructure : Roads and irrigation canals built by unskilled labour  are of very poor quality (₹ 3 trillion spent without tangible outcomes)  .
  • No attempt is made to impart skill among workers.
  • MGNREGA pushed up rural wages without having much of an impact on rural productivity
  • MGNREGA program has been found to distort labour markets
    • Construction companies complain that NREGA has affected the availability of labour  .
    • MGNREGA has contributed to farm labour shortage in states like Punjab & Haryana .

According to some experts whole ideology on which MGNREGA is based is flawed because it is trying to contain migration of labour. As B.R. Ambedkar pointed out nearly a hundred years ago, the real solution to rural distress is to be found in rapid industrialization as well as urbanization. Govt shouldn’t stop  time tested process of migration & instead provide more job facilities in urban centres.

Suggestions to improve

  • MGNREGA should have an intensified focus on marginalised communities in the most backward blocks
  • Emphasis  on skill development  
  • Act should  be linked with the Socio-Economic Caste Census to ensure better targeting. 
  • Fighting corruption through the use of IT and community-based accountability mechanisms
  • Suspend  the NREGA programme during peak farming periods
  • In order  to  create  the  productive  assets,  the  scheme  should  be  converged  with  related  programmes  in the department  of agriculture,  irrigation, animal  husbandry  and  road  transport.

Side Topic : Why  higher  women  participation  in  MGNREGA

Women  participation  in  the  flagship  rural  job  scheme  MGNREGA  has  clocked  around  51%  in financial  year  2015-16. 

  • Wage  differential:  in  informal  sector,  there  is  generally  greater  wage  differential  between man  and  women,  whereas  MGNREGA  provides  equal  wages
  • Work  near  to  home
  • Unskilled  work:  since  work  provided  in  MGNREGA  is  unskilled,  men  who  are  educated  or can  find  work  in  near-by  towns,  does  not  seek  work  and  women  from  household  take  part in  work.
  • Migration:  generally,  men    migrates  to  urban  areas,  leaving  women  behind who  in  turn  go  to  MGNREGA  
  • Work  place  facilities:  MGREGA  says  that  crèche  facility  must  be  made  available  at  worksite
  • Mobilisation  by  Self Help Groups  in  Kerala  and  other  organizations  in  Rajasthan.

This  show  that  if  equal  wages,  better  facilities  at  work,  working  facilities  closer  to  home  are  provided women  take  active  participation  in  work.  

Film Certification Issues

Film Certification Issues

This article deals with ‘Regulatory Bodies.’ This is part of our series on ‘Governance’ which is important pillar of GS-2 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Cases in news

2019 Nanak Shah Faqir certified by CBFC but not allowed to be screened in Punjab  
2018 Supreme Court in case related to Padmavat has laid down the law: Once a film has been cleared by the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC), it has the right to state protection for screenings. States cannot suspend screenings citing law and order concerns. 
2017 Board refused to issue a film certificate to  Lipstick Under My Burkha (2017),  claiming film  portrayed a woman’s “fantasy above life” &  contained sexual scenes, abusive words, audio pornography that degraded the Indian culture. 

Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC)

How CBFC work

  • CBFC was created under Cinematograph Act, 1952 & is a statutory body
  • Main function = regulate the exhibition of films
  • Headquartered in Mumbai
  • Central Government appoints  non-official members and a Chairman who constitute the Board 
  • CBFC has  nine Regional Offices  . 
  • Upon receiving an application for certification, relevant regional officer appoints an Examining Committee. Body assign each film to one of the four categories
    • U – Unrestricted public exhibition
    • A- Restricted to adults
    • UA –Unrestricted public exhibition (with word of caution that Parental discretion required for children below 12 years)
    • S – viewing by  special class of persons (for example: doctors)
  • If the applicant isn’t happy with the certification , he can apply to the Revising Committee
  • In case of persisting dissatisfaction ,  matter goes to independent Appellate Tribunal, whose members are appointed by I&B . Any further dispute goes to court.

Main Issues & Analysis

1 . Autonomy of CBFC

  • Cinematograph Act, 1952 empowers Central Government with overriding powers on censorship of films.
    • All members of CBFC including Chairman are appointed by and holds office “during the pleasure of the Central Government
    • Centre  can uncertify a film already certified.

2. Vagueness in language

  • Certification under Cinematograph Act, 1952 can be denied if it is against security of state, challenges sovereignty and integrity etc . All these are inline with restrictions on Freedom of Speech under Article 19(2)but  there is  no clause in Cinematograph Act that SC judgements on Article 19(2) should be kept in mind while making judgement. This create problem because CBFC interpret these terms vaguely and take upon itself the role of moral policing 

3. States overruling CBFC & Courts order

  • Even films with certificates have been stopped at the State level on a perceived threat to law and order. These include
    • Punjabi film Sadda Haq
    • Kamal Haasan’s Viswaroopam
    • Prakash Jha’s Aarakshan
    • Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s Goliyon Ki Rasleela Ram-Leela etc

4. Sticking only to Certification

  • CBFC does not always see itself as a certifying authority, but rather plays role of censor .
  • Even Shyam Benegal Report has suggested  that  CBFC should only certify a film.

Case for Censorship

A passage of a 1989 Supreme Court judgement (S. Rangarajan v P. Jagjivan Ram) says in part: “The combination of act and speech, sight and sound will have a strong impact on the minds of the viewers and can affect emotions. Therefore, it has potential for evil & Censorship by prior restraint is, therefore, not only desirable but also necessary.’’

Shyam Benegal Committee

Union Ministry of Information & Broadcasting constituted a committee headed by noted film-maker Shyam Benegal to look into revamping the film certification process by Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC).

Committee submitted its recommendations . Most important among them were

  • CBFC should only be a film certification body
  • In case, film goes beyond relaxation under Article 19(2), CBFC can deny certification. But  CBFC will have to give proper explanation
  • Members of Regional Boards which are selected by government should instead be selected by bodies like Film Federation of India (FFI), National Commission of Women (NCW) , National Commission for protection of Child Rights etc
  • More Categories : CBFC should be more specific and apart from U category
    • UA Category can be broken up into further sub-categories – UA12+ & UA15+.
    • A category should also be sub-divided into A and AC (Adult with Caution) categories.
  • In order to preserve Indian Cinemaevery applicant be asked to deposit the Director’s Cut in the NFAI(National Film Archives of India)  for preservation of Indian Cinema, instead of the certified version
  • Out-of-turn certification may be permitted for which the applicant would have to pay 5 times the fee 

Problems

  • Still not clear that whether Supreme Court’s judgement will be kept in mind regarding  Article 19(2) 
  • Similar recommendations were earlier given by committees like  Justice  Mudgal Committee in 2012  but nothing came out after that. 

Way forward

Government should quit the arena of film certification and let the body setup by Industry decide film certification. This is the model in place in all the democracies. In US , rating system is overseen by an industry body (Motion Picture Association of America) & difference in the potential box-office earnings of films allows filmmakers to make decisions based on market logic

Cricket Governance

Cricket Governance

Following the spot match fixing scandal in IPL and the issue of extreme political interference in the working of BCCI, the Supreme Court (SC) had appointed a committee to look into the matter under the chairmanship of former CJI RM Lodha  The Committee suggested sweeping reforms in the troubled BCCI. 

2015 : Supreme Court appointed Lodha Committee to improve cricket administration in India.

Recommendations of Lodha Committee

Analysing Legalising Betting

July 2018 : Law Commission has reported to Government of India that since it is impossible to stop illegal gambling in India, the only viable option is to “regulate” it . Law Commission has recommended “cashless” gambling

  • Transaction between Gamblers to be linked to PAN & Aadhar card
  • Cap on number of gambling transactions
  • Regulations to protect vulnerable groups from exploitation

Present Law

  • The law— gambling is largely governed by the Public Gambling Act of 1867
  • Only  gambling in ‘games of chance’ is prohibited. Games of skill have no restriction. This distinction essentially means horse-racing is only sport in India in which gambling is legal. 

Other problem (legal)

  • Betting is a state subject — to legalise sports betting pan India,  each state have to make law legalising it separately .
  • A shorter route would be for the Council of States to pass a resolution stating that Parliament should legislate on sports betting in national interest.

Arguments that betting should be legalised

  • Gambling cant be eliminated and thrives underground . Hence, it is better to regulate it.
  • Taxing the gambling will generate revenue which can be used in public welfare measures (about ₹20,000 crore in tax revenue)
  • It will reduce money laundering
  • Western Nations have legalised it and results are good. We can take example from other countries & sports like betting on football is legal in UK and this has helped in making football Premier League more attractive & opportunity to fans to bid legally on their teams .
  • Gambling is not new to India and is part of Indian traditions.
    • Betting on Horse races already legal in India
    • Naradasamriti describes gambling as lawful amusement when carried in public gambling houses
    • Kautilya also says gambling should be done in regulated way

Arguments that betting shouldn’t be legalised

  • Not good especially in India due to huge poverty in India. Given the bitter results, many states have banned lottery in India, since poor people spend their money to test their fortune .
  • Gambling will lead to other social evils like alcoholism, drug abuse, sex trade etc .
  • Lessons learned from Mahabharata : Pandavas and teachings of Gandhi .
  • It’ll be very difficult for the government to curb illegal cricket betting as it is very efficient closed-door system (why to pay tax if underground betting provide same without paying tax) .
  • India can take example from Brazil where socio-economic situation is more like India . In  2014(near World Cup) Brazil realised it was missing out on a huge revenue generator, and  made betting legal . This led to gambling addiction, and even a rise in crime.
  • If cricket betting is legalised, there will be efforts to fix more games. It will be a nightmare for law enforcement agencies.

Jail Reforms

Jail Reforms

This article deals with ‘Jail Reforms.’ This is part of our series on ‘Governance’ which is important pillar of GS-2 syllabus . For more articles , you can click here

Introduction

  • Oct 2018 :  Supreme Court formed a committee on prison Reforms headed by former Supreme Court judge, Justice Amitava Roy. (But this is not the first time that such a body is being set up, example being the Justice A.N. Mulla committee )
  • June 2017 : murder of a women life convict in Byculla women’s prison over missing ration

Punjab Cases

  • March 2019 : IG PS Umranangal given special treatment in Jail in blatant violation of Punjab Jail Manual
  • Evergreen issue : periodic seizure of drugs and mobile phones from inmates
  • 2012 Bibi Jagir Kaur : Special treatment given to her in Kapurthala Modern Jail

Problems with Prison System

  • Overcrowding : occupancy rate at all-India level was 114 %
  • Jail Manual Problem
    • Outdated Jail Manuals prepared during Colonial Times.
    • Prison management is a state subject. Therefore, there are great variations in Prison manuals among different states.
  • Frequent cases of Custodial Deaths, Custodial Suicides & Custodial Rapes
  • Undertrials : Number of under-trials constitute 67% of total inmates (UK : 20%) with major reasons being lack of money to obtain bail or delay in trial. NHRC has called this a case of blatant Human Right violation 
  • Neglect of health and hygiene and giving Insufficient food and inadequate clothing
  • Focus on retributive justice rather than reformation and rehabilitation
  • Availability of drugs inside the prisons
  • Access to mobiles to prisoners to beat the communication protocol.
  • Influential prisoners get concessions  privileges and favourable exemptions like recent V.K. Shashikala Case (Tamil Nadu)
  • Difficulty of re-integration in Society : No Vocal Training and  psychological help given so that prisoners on release can re-integrate in society. Most of times, jails produce hardened criminals instead of reformed person

Solutions

  • Surveillance & Monitoring :
    • Supreme Court last year ordered to install CCTV cameras in all the prisons in the country.
  • Reforms in bail laws– so that bail remains a norm and jail an exception for all people not just rich and affluent. It will address problem of Overcrowding and Undertrials
    • May 2017 – Law Commission headed by Justice (Retd) BS Chauhan highlighted  once again that bail is the norm and jail the exception  but it’s application is limited to rich and affluent while people from lower socio-economic strata languish in jails. Commission recommended to make it easier for all those awaiting  trial to obtain bail
    • Law Commission has also recommended to Amend CrPC such that (268 Report, 2017)
      • Those detained for an offence that would attract up to seven years’ imprisonment be released on completing one-third of that period (currently , it is half)
      • those charged with offences attracting a longer jail term, after they complete half of that period.
      • For those who had spent the whole period as undertrials, the period undergone may be considered for remission.
  • Focus on reformation – provide them vocational training, employing them meaningfully after release, creating an open prison system for non-hard core criminals etc. should be tried
  • Upgradation and Uniformity in Manuals  –
  • Justice Mulla Committee suggested setting up of a National Prison Commission as a continuing body to bring about modernization of prisons in India.
  • Implement National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) Guidelines to Custodial Deaths  : FIR should be filed and all cases must be reported  to the NHRC within 24 hours of their occurrence . Erring prison officials should be given exemplary punishment . 
  • Make Comprehensive anti-torture legislation – Even Supreme court has told government to consider passing a comprehensive anti-torture legislation
  • Reintegration within Society : Parivarthana programme taken up in Andhra Pradesh has proved to be a boon to prisoners to reform themselves and lead a dignified life after their release from jail. Under this, Parivarthana Centres have come up at district jail and sub-jails.
  • Option of Open Jails can also be considered which follows rehabilitative approach instead of retributive one.